Rights management discussion
I was on Seesmic earlier this evening, and fred2boro and I got into a discussion about rights on Seesmic. So allow me to summarize our brief conversation.
Right now, every video is assumed published, and can be redistributed (hence the embed link). Fair use? Not necessarily, but you are putting your stuff out there for all to see.
We need more rights management. And so does Seesmic.
(from here on out is my commentary, and not necessarily the opinions of fred2boro)
huh? We need more rights management. And so does Seesmic? I’m making a blanket statement for the web. Just like Flickr allows you to make a picture as public, friends, or family. That’s a start. Not many social networks provide this, but they should. And I think Seesmic is a prime place to provide this.
So this is what I think. Seesmic needs a flickr type system as I described above. Additionally, I would also like to see a way to send a personal message to someone. Effectively an email sent but with your video. So that is one level. One on one. Next, family. Clearly this all goes way past follow, which is also valuable, in fact, a different system all together. So family, I can mark people as family, and I can allow only family to see it. Same with friends. But I can also make things public, and that would be exactly how things are right now.
Your thoughts? Comments? You see things differently? You think I’m a nut? I would love to hear about it.
Tags: Flickr, fred2boro, Jeremy Vaught, rights management, seesmic
December 10th, 2007 at 12:33 am
Since this thread originally started it did make me think and if anything it has led me to post less on Seesmic than I used to.
The Flickr example is a good one. I fully distribute my photos that I upload to Flickr and the photo is a stand alone message, but a video that can be embeded out of context can be a very dangerous thing.
If I upload a video to YouTube I’m always aware of the message that the single video contains. it is a stand alone piece of media. But a Seesmic video as part of a greater conversation, can be a dangerous item used without permission and out of context.
Being open is good but being open with user controls and permission is even better. For now on Seesmic, I’ll probably be a lurker but not a poster.
December 12th, 2007 at 10:00 pm
[...] But he does make a point about rights that I raised here. [...]
December 17th, 2007 at 3:56 pm
[...] leads me to a soapbox rant I recently had. With friends, I hope rights management is soon to follow. It is also important to note what [...]